Hey Island Restaurant has a postcard view but a worse reality: empty buffet, glacial service and a crab papaya salad that made a guest sick
Border run = legal trick to reset your tourist visa. Exit Thailand, re-enter same day = new 60-day stamp.
- Get 60 new days (not 30)
- Same day return to Phuket
- All transport included
- 100% success guaranteed
Leave request → Manager will explain everything
FastTrack Thailand = skip 2-hour immigration queues. Personal escort meets you with name sign, guides to VIP lane. 2 hours → 15 minutes guaranteed.
- 2 hours saved every arrival
- Personal escort with name sign
- VIP immigration lane access
- From $40 - cheaper than expected
Book FastTrack → Save 2 hours today
Hey Island Restaurant — short verdict
Rating reality: The place sits at 3.4/5 from 24 reviews, a middle-of-the-road score that hides sharp extremes in guest reports. Operates every day 8:00 AM to 6:00 PM, so it functions as a daytime, tourist-oriented outlet rather than a night dining destination. If you care about consistent food safety and steady service, the data suggests caution; if you prioritize location and daytime island activities, it might still fit your plans.
What the numbers and dates reveal
- Overall rating: 3.4/5 based on 24 reviews.
- Review spread in the sample provided: one 5-star from 2017, a 4-star and two 1-stars and a 2-star between 2022–2024. Recent feedback skews negative.
- Operating hours: daily 8:00 AM–6:00 PM, which aligns with beach and tour schedules rather than evening dining.
Three angles that expose the real dining experience
1. Safety and trust: a documented food-poisoning event
One reviewer reported food poisoning after eating papaya salad with crab. That single account alone is a red flag you cannot ignore in a small-sample environment. Food-safety lapses can be episodic, but in a restaurant with fewer than a few dozen reviews, an acute complaint like poisoning has outsized significance.
Actionable takeaway: avoid raw or high-risk seafood dishes here until you see sustained, recent positive reports about them. If you have limited tolerance for food-safety risk, skip this restaurant altogether.
2. Value versus promise: buffet confusion and stingy refills
A guest who arrived with a group expected a Swedish table but found limited items and no refills when chicken or fruit ran out. Drinks were reportedly limited to water. That is a direct contradiction between perceived offering and delivery.
Operationally, this implies either poor supply planning or deliberate marketing puffery aimed at tour groups. For travelers relying on included meal promises, the result was inconvenience and disappointment.
Actionable takeaway: if you’re on a tour package that mentions a buffet or Swedish table at Hey Island, clarify in writing what is included and what happens when items run out. Bring extra snacks or budget for on-site purchases.
3. Service rhythm: slow, uneven pacing
One reviewer waited 20 minutes between their first and last dish. That’s not a minor hiccup; it’s symptomatic of poor kitchen sequencing or understaffing during peak tides of tourist traffic. In a daytime island setting open 8–18, those peaks matter — lunch rushes coincide with incoming boat tours.
Actionable takeaway: arrive early for service that is marginally faster, or plan for long waits if you visit midday. If time is limited because of boat schedules or excursions, factor in potential delays or choose food options that can be prepared quickly.
Context matters: location is the asset, food is a gamble
Multiple surrounding tourist attractions and bars are listed nearby, including Kahung Beach and several water-activity operators, which explains why several reviews focus on the island and activities rather than the cuisine. One 4-star reviewer explicitly praised the location more than the food.
That proximity to tourist infrastructure is a double-edged sword: it guarantees foot traffic and scenic advantage but also attracts customers who prioritize views and activities over dining quality. Restaurants in that niche often sacrifice kitchen consistency for throughput.
Actionable takeaway: pick Hey Island Restaurant if you want a convenient meal during island activities and value location above gastronomy. Skip it if your priority is culinary standards or fine service.
Putting the contradictions together
- Old praise versus recent complaints: a 5-star review from 2017 stands against several negative accounts from 2022–2024, suggesting either a decline in standards or inconsistent management across years.
- Marketing signals clash with delivery: advertised buffet style and actual shortages show possible overpromising to tour operators and underresourcing the kitchen.
- Tourist-oriented operating hours and surroundings point to a daytime, high-volume business model where speed and turnover matter more than quality control.
How to decide whether to go
If you value safety, predictable service, and good value for money, the data advises caution. If your travel plan centers on beach access, water activities, and a convenient lunch spot where location trumps everything else, the restaurant could serve that narrow purpose.
Practical, evidence-based tips
- Avoid risky seafood salads until you see updated, reliable positive reports about them.
- If your booking mentions a buffet or Swedish table, demand clarification about refill policies and included beverages before arrival.
- Time your visit for early morning or early lunch to reduce risk of slow service and food shortages.
- Bring snacks or cash for alternative options if the offered items run out.
- Expect a daytime-only operation; plan excursions around the 8:00 AM–6:00 PM window.
Final verdict
Hey Island Restaurant trades on location and tourist volume but shows cracks in food safety, service consistency, and truth in advertising. The 3.4/5 score masks a polarized set of experiences: an old glowing review and several recent, specific complaints about poisoning, poor buffet management, and slow service. Visit only if the view and location are your priority and you accept the risk that food and service may be hit-or-miss.
Short version: great island setting; questionable kitchen and service reliability; treat high-risk dishes and buffet promises with skepticism.
🕒 Opening Hours
7.745075, 98.375046
Comments are closed